In order to bring you the best possible user experience, this site uses Javascript. If you are seeing this message, it is likely that the Javascript option in your browser is disabled. For optimal viewing of this site, please ensure that Javascript is enabled for your browser.
 EMAIL TO FRIEND     |      PRINTER FRIENDLY     |    
          advertisement

Alternative Allergy Treatments

- Summary
- About
- Types and differences
- Conditions treated
- Tips when purchasing
- Questions for your doctor

Reviewed By:
Marc J. Sicklick, M.D., FAAAAI, FACAAI

Types and differences

Many healthcare experts believe that alternative allergy treatments are unlikely to help relieve allergy symptoms, and may even make symptoms worse. Patients should discuss any alternative tests or therapies they are considering with a board-certified allergist/immunologist.

Alternative allergy treatments that may be of questionable value include:

  • Hypnosis. An induced form of deep relaxation in which a patient is susceptible to suggestions from the practitioner. Though this is unlikely to cure allergy symptoms, a suggestion to clean up dust regularly or to avoid chocolate may help those suffering from allergies to practice avoidance.

  • Acupuncture and acupressure. Some claim that these ancient Chinese techniques can effectively treat symptoms of allergies and asthma. During acupuncture, thin, wire needles are used to stimulate certain points on the body. In acupressure, pressure from fingers or devices is substituted for needles.

    Many patients report reduced symptoms and need for medicine after this therapy, and some studies show that people do have lower levels of allergy-related antibody immunoglobulin E (IgE) in their blood after this therapy. Additional studies have suggested that acupuncture may be effective at treating allergic rhinitis (hay fever). However, the therapy has not been submitted to rigorous testing, and more definitive research is needed before the practice is adopted by the wider medical community.

  • Elimination diets. When performed under the direction of a physician, elimination diets are a legitimate allergy treatment used to identify foods that may cause allergic reactions in an individual. However, there are a number of non-medical practitioners who may offer this therapy as an “alternative” treatment. Attempting to practice this treatment without physician oversight and involvement may be ineffective and even dangerous. Patients who begin an elimination diet are at risk for losing key nutrients when they remove certain foods from their diet. In addition, individuals that consume a food allergen may experience anaphylaxis, a rare, severe allergic reaction that can interfere with a person’s ability to breathe or lead to shock.

  • Herbs and dietary supplements. One of the most popular alternative treatments, these are mostly derived from plant sources (as are about half of standard prescription drugs). Proponents often suggest using these as a substitute for various medicines. There is no evidence that these supplements work better than prescription drugs or allergy shots (immunotherapy), and some (such as ephedra) have been shown to be extremely harmful. Herbs and supplements can also have dangerous interactions with prescription drugs.

    For these reasons, most in the healthcare community urge patients to stay away from herbs and supplements and instead stick to proven prescription medicines. It is important to remember that herbal supplements are, in fact, drugs in a different form that are unregulated by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). The FDA cannot guarantee the claims made by the manufacturer, or that a product actually contains the active compound in the quality and amount necessary to treat a condition. Herbs and supplements that may be promoted as allergy treatments include:

    • Bitter orange (citrus aurantium). As a natural extract, bitter orange is on the FDA’s Generally Recognized As Safe (GRAS) list. However, this substance is similar to ephedra and therefore may pose similar health risks when used in supplements or herbal remedies.

    • Butterbur. Extracts of this plant are believed to relieve hay fever symptoms.

    • Bromelain. Derived from pineapples, this enzyme is thought to have anti-inflammatory properties.

    • Country mallow. A chemical stimulant found in some plants that is similar to ephedra and therefore may pose similar health risks.

    • Echinacea. An herb believed to have anti-inflammatory and immune system boosting properties. However, echinacea is a member of the ragweed family and some believe it is more likely to trigger symptoms than to prevent them. 

    • Ephedra (ma huang). A naturally occurring substance found in plants that provides the basis for the bronchodilator medication ephedrine. Once a common dietary supplement, ephedra was banned by the FDA in February 2004. The dangers of ephedra have been well-documented, including an increased risk of heart attacks and sudden cardiac death.

    • Evening primrose. Oil is extracted from the seed of this plant to treat a number of conditions, including skin rashes and hives related to allergies.

    • Grape seed extract. A substance derived from the seeds or skins of grapes that is believed to have natural antihistamine and anti-inflammatory properties.

    • Pycnogenol. An extract of maritime pine trees that is believed to have anti-inflammatory properties.

    • Quercitin. A substance found in some fruit and plants that is believed to have properties that enhance skin's elasticity and inhibit allergic reactions. It is promoted as a treatment for sinus reactions, hay fever (allergic rhinitis), skin conditions and asthma.

    • Spirulina. A class of algae that grows in mild to hot climates throughout the world. Though primarily promoted as a weight loss supplement (it has not been proven effective), it may also have antihistamine properties.

    • Stinging nettle. A supplement made from the stinging nettle plant, which is similar to poison ivy. It is promoted as a treatment for hay fever and skin conditions such as eczema.

    • Thymus extract. An extract produced by the thymus gland, usually of young cows. Though it is promoted as an allergy reliever, some also believe that this extract can help in preventing the development of allergic conditions.

    • Vitamin C. Some suggest that a daily dose of 1,000 to 4,000 milligrams should reduce the severity of sinus stuffiness and runny nose.

Alternative allergy treatments considered to be completely without merit by the general medical community include:

  • Homeopathy. Like treatments using allergy shots, homeopathy operates under the principle that exposing a person to a certain amount of an allergen can create a tolerance that eventually eliminates symptoms. However, there are major differences between the two therapies. In immunotherapy, the allergen is injected into the patient in increasingly greater concentrations until a tolerance is established. Conversely, homeopathy pills contain an extremely diluted plant and animal extract that is so small it is virtually undetectable in some cases.

    In addition, the substance in the pill usually is not the allergen itself, but another substance that causes similar symptoms. So, for example, onion extracts are used in hay fever remedies because onions cause the eyes to water and nose to run. Proponents of homeopathy maintain this approach allows patients to flush the allergy from their systems. Although some practitioners claim great success in using homeopathy to treat symptoms, science has not established its effectiveness.

  • Cytotoxic testing. A blood test that supposedly identifies food or inhalant allergies. However, a number of clinic trials have found these tests completely ineffective at diagnosing allergies, according to the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology (AAAAI). Such testing is therefore not recommended.

  • Laser therapy. Often advertised as a way to unblock clogged sinuses, laser therapy has benefits that are likely to be temporary and could trigger long-term side effects. These include scarring and fungus growth, which are likely to cause the patient’s original symptoms to return in a greater degree of severity.

  • Sublingual provocation and neutralization therapy. A combination therapy that supposedly identifies the allergen triggering allergy symptoms and then increases the patient’s tolerance of that allergen. It is unproven and not recommended by the AAAAI. The practitioner takes neutralizing substances – such as extracts of allergens, chemicals and foods – and injects them into the body or places them as drops under the tongue. Dosages are increased until the patient has a reaction. Once a reaction occurs, an allergy is diagnosed, regardless of whether or not an immune system response is involved. Additional doses of the allergen are then administered to “neutralize” the reaction.

    Research has not found such therapy to be effective, and some worry that it can in fact trigger allergy symptoms rather than reduce them. It is important to note that neutralization therapy is different from allergy shots, which have been proven effective in the treatment of a number of allergic conditions.

  • Antifungal and anti-yeast treatments. Designed to treat Candida (yeast) hypersensitivity syndrome, a condition that alternative medicine practitioners contend is a reaction to yeast in the body that normally does not cause trouble for people. These treatments include a diet that excludes foods that contain yeasts, such as breads. Some proponents also exclude sugar from these diets, believing it to be a contributor to yeast growth. Patients sometimes are required to take antifungal drugs, which most healthcare providers discourage because of a risk of liver damage. Most experts agree that there is no evidence to indicate that these treatments are effective.

  • Ayurvedic medicine. Practiced under the theory that impaired digestion creates allergies by allowing toxins to build up in the body. The therapy begins with fasting, and includes a rotating diet and the taking of herbs. Some practitioners also recommend a cleansing process that includes herbal massages, saunas, laxatives and enemas. Healthcare providers particularly warn against one treatment recommended by practitioners – colonic irrigation, which includes a powerful enema that has caused physical injury and even death on occasion.

  • Endpoint titration immunotherapy. The practitioner injects an allergen under the skin to desensitize a patient. This approach frequently works in conventional allergy shots. However, the doses of allergen used in endpoint titration immunotherapy are very low when compared to standard allergy treatments. Most medical experts agree that the doses are far too low to be effective.

  • Enzyme potentiated desensitization. A very low dose of an allergen is mixed with a protein molecule (the enzyme beta-glucuronidase) and injected under the skin. It is somewhat like allergy shot treatment, except a single injection is supposed to last a whole season. Again, this remains medically unproved.

  • Extreme environmental avoidance. Encouraging patients to avoid allergens is a sound treatment in traditional allergy practice. However, alternative practitioners take the practice to extremes, recommending the remodeling of entire homes to protect the patient from various chemical contaminants. Sometimes, a patient may be urged to move to isolated communities away from pollutants, or to wear a mask in public. Most medical experts view such measures as extreme and unnecessary.

Prev Page | page 3 of 6 | Next Page




Review Date: 06-19-2007
Video
Too Much TV Could Cause Asthma
Too much tube time for children may increase their risk for breathing...
Allergy
An allergy occurs when the body reacts to substances it can't tolerate.
Learning to Live with Asthma
Having an action plan to deal with asthma helps people keep symptoms...
Ah-chew! Tips for allergy sufferers
Ann Curry talks with Dr. Beth Corn about some soothing tips for...
Controlling Allergies
People with allergies have a range of treatment options available from over-the-counter...
Is it Allergy Season?
For some people, allergy season can last all year long. Listen in as experts describe the...

Advice from Dr. Nancy Snyderman

Dr. Nancy Snyderman

Helpful tips and information on weight loss

Get answers from an expert
advertisement
advertisement

YourTotalHealth      

Home  |  Health Centers  |  Health A-Z  |  Staying Healthy  |  Diet & Fitness  |  Woman & Family  |  Pregnancy  |  Community  |  

also on iVillage: Pregnancy & Parenting  |  Beauty & Style  |  Home & Garden  |  Food  |  Weddings  |  Love  |  Entertainment  |  NeverSayDiet

Terms of Service  |  Privacy Policy  |  Site Map  |  Newsletters  |  Feedback

Copyright (c) 2000-2009 iVillage Inc. All rights reserved. The information provided on this site is intended for your general knowledge only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice or treatment for specific medical conditions. You should not use this information to diagnose or treat a health problem or disease without consulting with a qualified healthcare provider. Please consult your healthcare provider with any questions or concerns you may have regarding your condition.